|
Feature
|
Distributing co-operative
|
Proprietary company
|
Public company with shares
|
|
Jurisdiction
|
State government.
|
Commonwealth government.
|
Commonwealth government.
|
|
Governing legislation
|
Co-operatives National Law.
|
Corporations Act.
|
Corporations Act.
|
|
Ownership of entity
|
Persons who use its services.
|
Small business investors.
|
Public investors.
|
Purpose of entity
|
To serve the needs of its members.
To increase income for business members.
To market goods and services of members.
To supply goods and services to members.
|
To attract and serve customers.
To provide employment for owners.
To earn profits for owners.
To increase value of business.
|
To attract and serve customers.
To earn profits for investors.
To increase value of shares.
|
|
Operating practices
|
Business done primarily with members.
|
Business done primarily with public.
|
Business done primarily with public.
|
Initial transaction
|
Purchase or sale is a conditional
transaction, with a discount or
added payment (rebate) made during or after end of financial year.
|
Purchase or sale is a complete
transaction.
|
Purchase or sale is a complete
transaction.
|
|
Minimum to form entity
|
Five
|
One, maximum 50.
|
One
|
|
Ownership rights
|
Tradeable to user members.
|
Restricted.
|
Tradeable to public investors.
|
Control of entity
|
User members.
Democratic control.
Vote attached to membership.
One member one vote.
|
Business owners.
Majority shareholder control.
Vote attached to shareholding.
One share one vote.
|
Investors.
Majority shareholder(s) control.
Vote attached to shareholding.
One share one vote.
|
|
Governance
|
Determined in rules.
|
Minimum one director.
|
Minimum three directors.
|
Raising funds
|
Member shares.
Retained earnings.
Debentures to members and public.
Bank lenders.
|
Business owners primarily.
Retained profits.
Bank lenders.
|
Shares to public.
Retained profits.
Debentures.
Bank lenders.
|
Shareholding
|
Only users can
own shares.
Total number of shares issued varies with number of members.
|
Any person can
own shares.
|
Any person can
own shares.
|
Share limit held by
any one shareholder
|
20% of total
shares issued.
|
No limit.
|
No limit.
|
Disclosure statement
to issue shares?
|
Yes
|
No
|
Only if required by Corporations Act.
|
|
Status of profits
|
Profits belong to user members.
|
Profits belong to the company.
|
Profits belong to the company.
|
Distribution of earnings
|
Rebates in proportion to
patronage.
Limited dividends.
Bonus shares.
|
In proportion to shares held.
Dividends.
Bonus shares.
|
In proportion to shares held.
Dividends.
Bonus shares.
|
|
Auditing of accounts
|
Exemption for small co-operatives.
|
Exemption for small companies.
|
Annually
|
|
Financial year
|
Any date in a calendar year.
|
Usually 30 June.
|
Usually 30 June.
|
|
Public inspection of share registers?
|
No
|
No
|
Yes
|